No. 12 Ohio State overcomes Penn State in 2OT, 31-24

Take note: Somewhat clean. The Buckeyes looked mortal against the Nittany Lions, if largely due to a number of avoidable — and, to Urban Meyer, likely frustrating — self-inflicted wounds. OSU committed eight penalties, several in the span of a single series in the second quarter to take the Buckeyes out of the PSU red zone. The offense found success in spurts but put together just one drive of 50 or more yards. While quarterback J.T. Barrett found lanes on the ground, the Buckeyes had just 52 passing yards at halftime. His pick-six on the second half's opening drive gave the Nittany Lions life, cutting OSU's lead to 17-7, and a second interception in the fourth quarter helped PSU trim the lead to 17-14 with 11 minutes left.
FOOTBALL FOUR: Rating and debating college football and the Playoff
It took overtime and a herculean pair of extra frames from Barrett for Ohio State to survive, and in the process significant questions were raised about this team's place in the championship hunt. How seriously can the Buckeyes be taken among other one-loss contenders when they can't put away a Penn State team still finding its way under first-year coach James Franklin and his staff?

WHAT WE'LL BE TALKING ABOUT: The Buckeyes will meet Michigan State on Nov. 8 with a season on the line — the Big Ten East Division crown, the Big Ten title, perhaps even a spot in the College Football Playoff. Yet after such a sluggish win, can we say the Buckeyes are complete enough — cohesive enough, consistent enough, balanced on both sides — to unseat the Spartans from their perch atop the conference? What beats Penn State might not beat Michigan State; an uneven showing, full of penalties and missteps, is not the recipe for success in East Lansing.
 Credit is due, however: Meyer and the OSU staff have maintained the Buckeyes' sense of purpose after September's loss to Virginia Tech, even if that looks less and less excusable as the Hokies stumble through Atlantic Coast Conference play. Ohio State's winning streak has vaulted it back into the national race while giving the Big Ten at least two and perhaps three — if we count Nebraska — contenders for the Playoff. Has Ohio State bounced back? No, not yet. But the Buckeyes have given themselves the opportunity to match their preseason expectations.
 WHAT WE'LL BE TALKING ABOUT, PART II: This was Big Ten officiating at its worst. From a terribly botched replay of an Ohio State interception — an almost comical error by the replay crew — through several questionable calls, flags and spots, neither offense was able to develop any pace or tempo during the second half. As if the offenses weren't spotty enough without the help. The feather in the crew's hat? Calling timeout on Ohio State's behalf before Sam Ficken's game-tying field goal in the fourth quarter — even if Urban Meyer didn't signal for a timeout.